中国循证儿科杂志 ›› 2020, Vol. 15 ›› Issue (1): 25-31.

• COVID-19特稿·论著 • 上一篇    下一篇

基于8篇病例系列报告和10篇病例报告的儿童新型冠状病毒肺炎流行病学、临床特征和出院结局的系统综述

葛艳玲1,王瑞2,常海岭1,曾玫1,张崇凡2   

  1. 国家儿童医学中心 复旦大学附属儿科医院1 感染传染科;2 临床指南制作和评价中心上海,201102
  • 收稿日期:2020-03-31 修回日期:2020-03-31 出版日期:2020-02-25 发布日期:2020-03-16
  • 通讯作者: 张崇凡
  • 基金资助:
     

Epidemiology, clinical characteristics and discharge outcomes of children with COVID19 based on eight case series studies and 10 case reports: A systematic review

 GE Yan-ling1,WANG Rui2,CHANG Hai-ling1,ZENG Mei1,ZHANG Chong-fan2   

  1.  Children's Hospital of Fudan University: 1 Department of Infectious Disease; 2 Center for Clinical Practice Guideline Development and Evaluation, Shanghai 201102, China
  • Received:2020-03-31 Revised:2020-03-31 Online:2020-02-25 Published:2020-03-16
  • Contact: ZHANG Chong-fan
  • Supported by:
     

摘要: 目的总结儿童严重急性呼吸综合征冠状病毒2 (SARS-CoV-2)感染病例的流行病学、临床特征和出院结局,为指导SARS-CoV-2感染的防治提供证据。方法纳入确诊的新型冠状病毒肺炎(COVID-19)年龄1个月至18岁儿童病例。排除SARS-CoV-2核酸检测试剂、分子诊断等文献,成人文献中无法单独提取儿科数据的文献。在PubMed、CBM和中国知网数据库检索,并在WHO COVID-19文献数据库和纳入文献的参考文献中进行补充检索,检索起止时间:2000年1月1日至2020年3月11日。由感染传染专业副主任医师提取文献数据并行文献偏倚风险评价,临床实践指南制作和评价专业人员行文献偏倚风险评价培训和审核。结果共18篇文献进入系统评价,中、英文文献分别为13篇和5篇,病例报告10篇,3/8篇病例系列报告为可接受偏倚风险。127例儿童COVID-19均为SARS-CoV-2核酸检测阳性,年龄1 d至 17岁,男性66例(52%)。有湖北疫区的居留史、或旅游史、或与湖北人士接触史占58%(74/127),家庭聚集性病例占75%(79/105)。9/11篇文献描述确诊时间1~3 d。72例有发热和具体体温值,37.3~39℃ 43例,>39℃ 6例。7/10篇文献描述热程为1 d。11篇文献中描述有咳嗽症状(47例);6篇文献描述有鼻塞/流涕/喷嚏症状(14例),4篇文献中描述了腹泻、呕吐症状(10例),其中4例为首发症状,包括1例危重症;7篇文献中有26例无明显症状(20%,26/127),其中有15例影像学提示肺炎。16篇文献(105例)报告了血常规,WBC (3.2~16.71)×109·L-1,淋巴细胞绝对值减少2例;17篇文献(126例)行影像学检查,11例胸部X线检查4例表现为单侧炎性渗出,115例进行了胸部CT检查:有和无肺炎征象分别为80例(70%)和35例。80例CT有肺炎征象的患儿中,磨玻璃影57例(71%),小结节/实变影(可与磨玻璃影共存)42例(52%),网格影4例,类支气管肺炎改变3例。轻型47例,普通型78例,危重型2例。73例(57%)行抗病毒治疗,包括干扰素、帕拉米韦/奥司他韦、利巴韦林、克力芝(洛匹那韦/利托那韦)、阿比多尔、达芦那韦/考比司他等, 11例应用了中成药,3例未接受任何治疗。46例出院或鼻咽拭子SARS-CoV-2核酸转阴时间5~22 d。最长观察到30 d粪便SARS-CoV-2核酸检测仍然阳性。结论儿童COVID-19病例以家庭聚集性发病多见;多为轻型和普通型病例,热程短,呼吸道症状轻微,出现症状至确诊时间短,预后良好。

 

Abstract: Objective To summarize the epidemiological, clinical characteristics and discharge outcomes of children with COVID-19 and to provide evidence to guide the prevention and treatment of COVID-19. MethodsConfirmed COVID-19 cases of children aged from 1 month to 18 years were included. We excluded articles on SARS-CoV-2 nucleic acid detection reagents and molecular diagnosis and those from which children's data could not be extracted. Literature was searched in the database of PubMed, CBM and CNKI from January 1st, 2019 to March 11th, 2020 and a supplementary search was performed in the WHO COVID-19 literature database and references of the included literature. Risk of bias assessment was conducted by the associate chief physician of Department of Infectious Disease in Children's Hospital of Fudan University. Literature evaluation and data extraction were instructed and reviewed by professionals from Center for Clinical Guideline Development and Evaluation in Children's Hospital of Fudan University. ResultsA total of 18 literature was included according to the eligibility criteria with 13 in Chinese and 5 in English. Among them, there are 10 case reports and 8 case series reports, 3 of which had acceptable risk of bias. One hundred and twenty-seven children with COVID-19 were identified including 47 of mild type, 78 of common type and 2 of critical type. They were at the age of 1 day to 17 years with 66 males (52%) and were all tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 nucleic acid. The number of cases with history of residence or travel in Hubei Province or contact with people from Hubei Province, and cases of family clustering accounted for 58%(74/127)and 75%(79/105)respectively. Of 11 literature mentioning the time for diagnosis, 9 described it as 1-3 days. Seventy-two cases had fever and specific body temperature values with 43 cases at 37.3-39℃, and 6 cases at >39 ℃. Of 10 literature mentioning fever duration, 7 described it as 1 day. Coughing, nasal congestion/runny nose/sneezing, diarrhea and vomiting, and asymptomatic children were respectively identified in 11 literature (47 cases), 6 literature (14 cases), 4 literature (10 cases with 1 critical illness and 4 of first symptoms) and in 7 literature (26 cases with 15 of pneumonia by imaging) . A total of 16 literature (105 cases) reported routine blood test results with WBC 3.2-16.71 (×109·L-1) and 2 of decrease in absolute lymphocytes. Imaging examinations were performed in 126 cases from 17 literature. Four of 11 cases of chest X-ray showed inflammatory exudation at one side and there were 80 cases (70%) with signs of pneumonia and 35 cases (30%) without that in 115 cases undergoing chest CT. Among the 80 children with CT signs of pneumonia, there were 57 for ground-glass shadows (71%), 42 for small nodules/consolidation shadows (52%) (coexisting with ground-glass shadows), 4 for grid shadows and 3 for bronchopneumonia-like changes. Seventy-three cases (57%) received antiviral therapy including interferons, peramivir/oseltamivir, ribavirin, Kaltera (lopinavir/ritonavir), arbidol, darunavir/cobicistat, etc. ; 11 cases were treated with Chinese patent medicine and 3 cases did not receive any treatment. Forty-six children were discharged or tested negative for SRAS-CoV-2 by nasopharyngeal swabs after 5 to 22 days. The longest disease duration was 30 days that nucleic acid test by stools still remained positive at the 30th day of observation. ConclusionChildren with COVID-19 were more common in family clusters. They were featured by mild and common types with short fever duration, mild respiratory symptoms, short intervals between the onset of symptoms and diagnosis and a good prognosis.

中图分类号: